“What,” you say? “We’re already understaffed and we can’t add any more programs that compete for our members’ attention!” Hold on a second and read. ;)
In his book, Purple Cow, Seth Godin discusses transforming your business by being remarkable. One of his questions was, “If you had to create a product or service to compete with yours, how would you do it?”
We know that chambers of commerce are facing competition from industry associations, networking groups, online communities and sometimes other chambers of commerce. And, the Gen X and Gen Y business owners are less likely to “join” an organization like a chamber. Plus, the current economic climate is forcing businesses to justify every dollar spent. So, if you were going to create a new chamber of commerce (or other organization) to compete with yours, what would you do?
Would you:
- Offer very low membership dues and a clearly defined list of benefits?
- Create high-end memberships and promote the “spend more –get more” idea of being connected at the highest level?
- Offer a la cart membership options so businesses could customize their membership to their needs?
- Offer “free” memberships but charge reasonable fees for all services?
- Deliver regular, personal communications to each member demonstrating their return on investment to help increase member retention?
- Find more ways to connect member businesses to new clients, local or otherwise?
- Deliver such outstanding service that your existing members consistently generated new member sales for you via word of mouth?
- Reach out to your audience, find out what’s important to them and engage them in more personal conversations?
- Help your small business members succeed by offering educational programs in-person and on-demand, so they can view them on their schedule?
How would you use technology to accomplish your goals? Would you:
- Use customer relationship management tools that give you the operational, collaborative and analytical tools you need to log, monitor and report on all member and prospect activity?
- Utilize member intelligence to help you make better decisions for managing and marketing your organization?
- Employ social media as a low cost way to extend your reach and develop a loyal base of connected members?
- Share information with others to become as transparent as possible in hopes of developing long-lasting relationship and foster trust?
Now that you’ve thought about what someone might do to take your members, go create those programs and services, get the technology needed to do so and retain more members! Of course, this means that some long-established programs may cease to exist, but consider this: If you were starting a new chamber to compete with yours, would it make good business sense to create the programs in question?
The exercise here is not to actually compete with yourself, but rather to think like your competition. By thinking of how you might compete with yourself, then developing new products, services and culture around these ideas, you’ll be a more flexible and responsive organization. And that is something that can improve your members’ satisfaction - and ultimately, your bottom line.

Posted by: Cathi Hight on Sunday, December 28, 2008
Curt, great article and good points for chambers to consider. Hope you are doing well and look forward to working with you more in 2009!
Posted by: Tammy Kerr on Thursday, May 14, 2009
Very thought provoking and a great way to remind us that someone is always better and there is always room for improvement. Thank you!